Boston’s Mysterious Vanishing Men

To read Part 2 Click Here

To view an interactive map of all cases Click Here

If you were to hear of a young man disappearing after a night of partying and ending up dead in a river, you might be quick to call it a tragic accident. You might think it was common almost, for young foolish drunk men to die in this manner. But why would you think that? One possibility is that you have heard of the sheer number of cases that seem to indicate this scenario. But what if this isn’t what is occurring at all? What if something far more sinister is taking place?

The trouble with these cases, the thing that got my attention, is also the very thing that seems to make them so dismissible. They are incredibly predictable. In fact in many cases they are practically cookie cutter. But some are so similar that they seem to go far beyond coincidence.

After my obsession with unexplained missing persons cases was sparked by David Paulides (as chronicled in my last post) I couldn’t help but begin to notice them more, and then Dennis Njoroge went missing. I saw flyers posted all around Boston, his eyes following me daily, and my heart fell. I had a bad feeling in my gut as I began to connect him to other cases. I remember telling friends gravely that if the precedent was correct, he would be found dead in the Charles River.

One month after he went missing, Dennis was found in the Charles. The Police did not suspect foul play, but very little information has ever been made public (and not for lack of trying let me tell you).

I don’t know what happened to Dennis, and maybe the police and his family do. Maybe he was a troubled boy who met a tragic but self inflicted end that cold December night. The fact is I might never know the truth due to the privacy of the family, but regardless, Dennis sparked in me the desire to go back and examine other similar cases in my city. Other cases where the truth seems hard to come by.

I decided to begin my own investigation of sorts, and I’m going to use this page to track my findings and hopefully bounce ideas off of others who are interested.

Here are the cases I have found so far, showing name, age, and month/year missing.

John Daverio (49)  3/2003

Dustin Willis (26) 3/2007

William Hurley (24) 10/2009

Eugene Losik (26) 2/2010

David Mark (24) 2/2011

Franco Garcia (21) 2/2012

Jonathan Dailey (23) 10/2012

Eric Munsell (24) 2/2014

Josue Quispe (18) 10/2015

Dennis Njoroge (21) 11/2015

Zachary Marr (22) 2/2016

And now I will take a closer look at each of the cases.

johndaverio

John Daverio was a beloved 49 year old teacher at Boston University. He was born in Philadelphia, and moved to Boston to get a PhD from BU. He later became the Chairman of the Department of Musicology there in 1987, a position he held until his death. He was considered one of the world’s leading experts on German Romanticism and Robert Schumann, whom he wrote several books about. (Ironically Schumann once attempted suicide by throwing himself into the Rhine river.) John was considered a happy man by all who knew him, and was lovingly caring for his elderly parents, indicating that suicide was unlikely.

Daverio was last seen on CCTV leaving the BU campus on the evening of March 16, 2003 at around 8:30pm, wearing a red jacket. He had left his wallet and briefcase behind in the classroom, but was carrying a white bag which was never found. After being missing nearly a month, his body was found in the Charles River on April 14, 2003, near the Cambridge Boathouse. Police did not suspect foul play, but his death has never been explained. Those close to him refused to believe he would commit suicide.

Dustin Willis11270_1

Dustin ‘Dusty’ Willis was from Hatteras, North Carolina. He became a PO3/E4 petty officer and Engineer in the Navy and was stationed in Norfolk, Virginia, as a crewman aboard the S.S. Donald Cook. Dustin was a musician, and was married but seperated, with a five year old son.

When Dustin was 26 the Donald Cook docked in Boston for Saint Patrick’s Day celebration. On the night of March 16th 2007 there were blizzard conditions in Boston. Dustin was out with his shipmate friends at the Black Rose Pub near Quincy Market. On their way out at around 11pm, Dustin’s shipmates lost sight of him in the storm. Friends state that he was sober at the time. He had spoken with his girlfriend several times that evening, and she confirmed this. When she called his phone the final time that evening a person that was not Dustin answered, and told her that they had found his phone. Dustin’s phone was found at about 1am on the ground near Long Wharf, but there was no sign of Dustin.

On March 21st Dustin’s body was found in 22 feet of water off Long Wharf, steps away from where his phone was found. Police surmised that he had simply become disorientated by the blizzard and slipped into the harbor.

imageScreen shot 2016-07-31 at 2.12.22 PM

William Hurley was a Navy sailor from North Carolina. He was stationed in Florida. On a stop in Boston in 2007 he met his girlfriend, and the two began dating. (Ironically he was in Boston the very same night that Dustin Willis went missing.) That December he moved from Florida to Quincy to live with her. William was invited by his friend Brendan Venti to attend a Bruins game at the TD Garden on October 8th 2009. However after only the first period and a couple of beers, he claimed he was tired from work, and was going to have his girlfriend pick him up. William stepped outside and called her, and she headed to pick him up. When she was close by she asked where he was. William asked a passerby who answered “99 Nashua Street”, and warned his girlfriend his phone was about to die. She told him she would be there in a moment and was just around the corner, then William’s phone died. When she got to the location, William wasn’t there. She drove around looking for him and asking people if they had seen him, but it was as if he had vanished into thin air. The search for William Hurley began but little leads were found. At some point his cellphone was found smashed, but Police released few details.

On October 14th William’s body was found at about 2:30am in the Charles River near 200 Nashua Street, 25 feet from shore. Police ruled out a mugging gone wrong as he had no injuries and his wallet and keys were still on him. Suffolk District Attorney Spokesman Jake Wark was quoted as saying the body had been in the water “a couple of days”. Perhaps it was a simple mistake, but William had been missing for six days, not a couple.

imageScreen shot 2016-07-31 at 2.15.14 PM

Eugene ‘Gene’ Losik was born in Belarus, and moved to the US when he was 7. He was an engineering grad of UMass Amherst, and a black belt in karate. He was 25 years old, living in Lawrence with his girlfriend and working for a company called Raytheon. On February 20th 2010 Gene was in the city celebrating a friend’s birthday. The group was staying at the Marriott Long Wharf hotel. After a night of partying, Gene was caught on CCTV at 2:24am leaving out the back entrance of the hotel without a jacket. He was heading into Christopher Columbus park, and friends say he was relatively sober and may have been stepping out for a cigarette. When friends awoke the next day they realized Gene was gone, and began to search. Police were led down to the docks by various scent dogs, and the water was searched by divers, but Gene was not found.

Nearly nine months later, on November 8th, Gene’s body was found near Rowes Wharf in the Boston Harbor. His cause of death is still unknown. Also unknown is why his body wasn’t found for six months, as drowning forensics indicate that it should have surfaced sooner. Some say it could have been weighted down, but the truth may never be known.

a9ab17b4217b57c5c5d0bad76944c388BostonBaseballTrip2008012.jpg

David Mark grew up in New York and had a Masters in Geography from the University of Albany. David had Type 1 Diabetes and was insulin dependent, and also had Aspergers. He was 24 when he went missing. On March 2nd 2011 David left the home where he lived with his parents in Albany and drove to Boston, where his sister lived in the Chestnut Hill area. David went and ate at Boston Beer Works near Fenway and had a few drinks. Employees said he was in good spirits. David never showed up at his sister’s house, and never returned home to Albany. The search for him was underway fast, as his parents knew he could Get sick without his insulin. His car was found several days later in Chestnut Hill, at 10 Middlesex Rd. but there was no sign of David. His phone was last pinged at around 6:40 in Boston, near the Charleston Naval Yard.

On March 8th a Boston fishing company found David’s body in the Chelsea River, downstream from the Andrew McArdle Bridge, 15 feet from shore. Police said there was no signs of trauma. His cause of death was not made public, but police say it was not foul play.

1334324759944maryanns

Franco Garcia grew up in West Newton with his Peruvian parents. He was attending a Boston College night school and studying chemistry, hoping to eventually go on to medical school. He worked full time at a CVS pharmacy in Waltham, and was musically gifted. On February 21st 2012 Franco was out with friends at Mary Ann’s Bar in Cleveland Circle. He was 21 at the time. He had made plans to spend the night with his friend Katherine Corteselli, though he flitted between several friend groups over the course of the evening. At 11:27pm he texted her a reminder: “Don’t leave without me”. Sometime after 12:15am friends lost sight of Franco, though his keys and jacket were still in the bar. At 12:18am Franco was caught on CCTV passing by an atm and heading toward Chestnut Hill Reservoir, and the area where his car was parked. He was not staggering, and friends described him as drunk but not smashed. His phone was last pinged about an hour later in the same area, but his car was left untouched. A huge search for Franco began, and his story was even shared by Bruce Springsteen. Police focused their search on the reservoir almost immediately, and searched it thoroughly, but nothing was found.

On April 11th at around 8am, Franco’s body was spotted in the weeds about 18 feet offshore in the reservoir. His wallet was still on him, and he had no injuries. Police described his death as being “consistent with an accidental fall into the water” but failed to elaborate on what that meant or why he wasn’t found before.

12661748_10208996069724053_7035494590759036316_n

Jonathan Dailey (FB)

Jonathan Dailey grew up in Charlotte, North Carolina and played violin and piano. He studied architectural technology at Appalachian State University, and later moved to Massachusetts with friend and roommate Miles Smith. Jonathan was 23 and attending a grad program at Boston Architectural College, but was taking a semester off for financial reasons. The night of October 2nd 2012, he and Miles hung out and had pizza until Miles went to bed around 9. The next morning Jonathan was gone. He had left behind everything but his phone. Though attempts were made to reach him he never answered, and his phone was soon shut off.

On October 9th at about 7:30am, a rowing instructor near Boston University (about a mile from Jonathan’s Allston apartment) made a startling discovery in the in the Charles River. Jonathan’s body was tied with chains to a cinderblock at the bottom of the river. Police assured the public that there was no threat to safety, and implied that Jonathan had committed suicide. He had no history of mental illness.

ericm1-e1398373768551554e66c9ce48a0.59948876-vpp_large

Eric Munsell was born in New Brunswick, New Jersey. He went to Boston University and got a degree in aerospace engineering. He was working as an aviation engineer at General Electric, and was pursuing a Masters in mechanical engineering via the Edison Engineering Program. On February 8th 2014, Eric was celebrating his 24th birthday at the Market Lounge. He was escorted out by a bouncer at about 11:30pm for causing a disturbance on his way to the restroom. It was only 18 degrees out, but according to the bouncer Eric claimed not to have a jacket. A half hour later his phone was pinged heading toward the Harbor and not his North End apartment. He was caught on CCTV near the Marriott Long Wharf.

On April 23 at about 12:30pm Eric’s body was found in the water at the end of Long Wharf. Police did not find his death suspicious. Why he supposedly walked to Long Wharf then proceeded to fall into the water and drown is unexplained.

Screen shot 2016-02-19 at 4.41.21 PM

r1C-0Dpf

Josue Quispe-Almendro was a runner, a photographer, and a religious young man. He lived in Malden with his tight knit family and was just 18 when he went missing. Josue was out running errands with his brother on October 17th 2015. He dropped his sibling off at a Bed Bath and Beyond in Somerville at about 4:30pm. He failed to return home or answer his phone. His car was found then next day at 10pm in Quincy.

Josue’s body was found washed up on Saquish Beach in Plymouth on November 12th. The cause of death was not released but police said foul play was not suspected. How Josue got all the way to Plymouth is unknown.

Screen shot 2016-02-19 at 5.01.18 PM

admin-ajax

Dennis Njoroge was born in Kenya, and moved with his mother to Worcester MA. He was attending Northeastern University and was an aspiring filmmaker who loved Quentin Tarantino and playing basketball. Dennis was excited to soon start a co-op job at a Boston News Station. He was 21 years old. On November 29th friends saw Dennis playing basketball at the Marino Center on Northeastern’s campus. This was verified by his keycard swipes. The next day he spoke to his mother on the phone, a conversation that she felt was perfectly normal. After that Dennis did not show up for classes, and did not respond to his mother. His phone was last pinged at around 2am on the MIT Campus in Cambridge.

On December 31st at 10am Dennis’ body was found by a jogger in the Charles River on the Boston side, near the esplanade and Arthur Fiedler Footbridge. The location is directly across from the MIT campus. There was no signs of trauma, and police were investigating the death as a “non-homicide”.

20160217_111141_marr_200bellhand

Zachary Marr (UPDATED) grew up in Harvard MA. He was celebrating his 22nd birthday with his cousins at the Bell in Hand Tavern on February 13th 2016. At about 1:30 he went outside for a cigarette, leaving his coat behind. At 1:40 he sent a snapchat to his cousin Amanda Marr that said “They won’t let me back in, lets leave”. She agreed to come out. However when they got outside Zach was gone. According to CCTV and bouncer statements, Zach never asked to come back inside. He was caught on CCTV at 1:44 walking past Boston Public Market, heading in the direction of TD Garden and Zakim Bridge. Police later found CCTV footage of Zachary “entering” the water under the Zakim (this footage has not been released). It is unclear what that meant precisely, but teams immediately began to search the water in the area. Nothing was found, possibly due to extremely low visibility. Several more searches were conducted with similar results in that area of the Charles River. On March 15th 2016 at about 5:45pm passerby’s noticed a body in the water by the Museum of Science Boston and (ironically) the Leverett Circle State Police Barracks. It was Zachary. His body was found in a location consistent with previous searches. Why he left the Bell in Hand and walked about a mile to the Charles is still unknown.

Some more thoughts on Zach Marr

********

I made a visualization of where the victims were last seen vs where their bodies were found.

Screen shot 2016-02-19 at 11.02.41 PM

I think its particularly beneficial to take a closer look in the financial district.

Screen shot 2016-02-19 at 11.18.57 PM

The proximities of these establishments is incredible.

Furthermore, many of the the victims are related in other ways.

  • William Hurley, Dustin Willis, and Jonathan Dailey were all from North Carolina.
  • Willis and Hurley were both in the Navy.
  • Willis, Gene Losik, and Eric Munsell were all engineers. Franco Garcia was studying chemistry.
  • Garcia, Willis, Dailey, and John Daverio were all musically talented. Josue Quispe was a photographer and Dennis Njoroge was a filmmaker.

Furthermore some cases seem bizarrely linked.

Dustin Willis was a NC native who joined the Navy and was in Boston March 16 2007. William Hurley was a NC born Navy man who was in Boston that same night, and would disappear two years after Willis. Both were talking on the phone to their girlfriends seconds before vanishing. Both men’s phones were later found.

Eric Munsell was removed from a bar on his birthday without his coat, possibly told a bouncer that he didn’t have one, and vanished into the night. Zachary Marr walked out of a bar without a coat two years later on his birthday, and told his friends that he wasn’t being allowed back inside. Both were later caught on CCTV.

I can’t claim to know just now what any of this might mean. all I can do is present the puzzle pieces that we currently have, but I know we are still missing far too many.

What I am certain of is that something terrible is happening to people all over the country, maybe the world, and the Boston cases are only a small sampling of it. I hope that someday this mystery can be solved to prevent future deaths, and pain for their families. Until then I urge everyone to make sure that YOU are not the next victim. Do not go out alone. Do not go near the water alone. And if possible, avoid wearing the color red. It’s a color that shows up often in David Paulides’ missing persons cases, and William Hurley and John Daverio were both wearing it when they vanished.

More On Zachary Marr

Part 2

 

Advertisements

1,594 thoughts on “Boston’s Mysterious Vanishing Men

  1. Have you considered that the similarities…cold, no jackets, left hot establishments (quick drop in body temp), drinking…could be all be contributing factors to hypothermia which would cause them to become confused and disoriented. None of them had signs of a struggle or injuries and all were young men who would be able to defend themselves.This seems a more logical explanation than something sinister.

    • Possibly in some cases, but in recollecting my earlier years that I came out of hot bars and had been drinking, I remember feeling more awake and more oriented when I hit the cold air. There were also a number of them that were not drinking, or had a couple and were relatively sober, so this explanation doesn’t wash with me in those cases, in particular. In these cases and even in some of the other cases nationwide there is cause for suspicion. A couple of them were Navy guys and used to navigating around vessels in ports in large bodies of water after being out in ports and very likely drinking as well. The circumstances surrounding those cases certainly have inspired me and many other people that I personally know to question these cases, and rightly so. Why wouldn’t we? Look at the case of Jonathan Dailey. As someone else on this blog stated, he walked 5 or 6 blocks from his apartment to the BU Bridge with a cinder block as well as chains and nobody noticed him? Really? Also, assuming that he went off the bridge, the logistics of him doing this without being seen are questionable, particularly if you look at the time it would take him to accomplish this. Iif you take a look at that bridge, it’s not something that a person can just leap over with a cinder block and chains. It’s solid concrete from top to bottom, approx 4 or 4.5 ft high with a “railing” that’s approx 2 feet across. That would take some time to do. I agree that some of the the cases nationwide appear to be accidents or self-inflicted, but others look very sinister to me as well as to many others. People instinctively know when something is off.

    • Way to many people in Boston not to hear someone’s cry for ‘help I’m drowning! No matter what time it is. Plus no woman nd every one thing, male and between 20-30?

  2. Most women and older people aren’t outside in the cold without a coat. Then again, you aren’t explaining why these men have no signs of a struggle either, so I guess we could go back and forth. I’m just offering a reasonable alternative to your theory.

    • Many of the men did. And many of the bodies have had things happen but not distinguishable from normal trauma from a body that’s in the river. I mean I understand not going back and forth, but once an anomaly is astablished the obv explainations no longer apply.

      • Not only that Richard Smith from Gloucester was found in the waters of the Muddy River but his phone was last pinged in the area of North Station? Does that ring a bell with Michael Kelleher disappearing from the TD Garden which is in the North Station area and the other kid William Hurley also disappearing from the TD Garden North Station area in 2009. They all ended up dead in the Charles and Muddy rivers… very spooky!

    • David Smith’s phone last pinged at North Station in August, 2016. His brother said he would never have gone off like that with their father being ill.

    • David Smith’s made his last known call from his phone at North Station in August, 2016. His brother said he would never have gone off like that for as long a period as he did with their father being ill and also leaving his dog alone.

  3. This is too similar these stories are too much alike theres something going on these arent just coincidences theres no way everything down to there phones jackets there courses there studying to few not drinking with no mental illness ever recorded this is very weird and to me something is happening to these people to make them do this this isnt something normal these men are very smart and young it doesnt make sense and why they arent found for about 2 months in the water and how almost all of them say they tripped in shore makes no sense at all some heavy investigating needs to take place cuz this sounds very odd to me

  4. David Smith also had some kind of medical condition or illness and needed daily medication to survive but didn’t have his medication with him.

  5. I never understood how these men tend to separate from their friends and leave the bar, arena, etc. by themselves. You would think they would be more careful considering how many young men and women are missing in this country.

  6. Also, why isn’t there a national task force to get to the bottom of this? Why is there no footage, ever, on CCTV,at the point of the disappearance? Why aren’t the coroners letting the cause of death be publicized? Something is definitely fishy. A young intelligent man named Dakota James just ended up in the river while out on the town with friends in PA. He was found dead but we never heard anything else about it.

  7. Pingback: The Allure of the Drink to Drinkers. A Boston Mystery | Trekking Toward The Truth

  8. Not sure if its possible but what if they were hypnotized to be triggered by something related to going to a bar? Which would indicate technically there is a serial killer but doing it in an unconventional way. Would explain the no struggle and the fact no one is ever caught on CCTV with these people.

  9. This is an interesting story because the Pittsburgh area has seen a string of similar cases over the past few years. In looking at these victims, there is an eerie similarity between the ones mentioned here and the ones being found in Pittsburgh.

  10. So ahhh, any of you hear about the body of a young male in his 20’s found in the river near the Boston Hatch Shell/Eaplanade on 04/22/17 *earth day* I live in Southie with my Fiance’ which is only about 5 miles away (if that). I actually just celebrated a year clean/sober (from Heroin, etc.) so I really dislike going to bars/clubs to drink 7up + I’m 36 years old. And I am very aware of my surroundings, some would say even hypervigilant. And trust me, I can handle my own. So I’m not particularly nervous about myself, I’m almost 6 ft. tall 210 lbs 😁 but I DO worry about friends and strangers alike in the area that don’t deserve to go out like that 😦

  11. Pingback: Boston’s Vanishing Men Mystery – Accident or Murder? | 1 Search

  12. Pingback: Boston’s Vanishing Men Mystery – Accident or Murder? | D.E. Alexander

  13. Elise, I heard you on Crawlspace, which reminded me that there are three cases that have had almost no press. Last year there was a blurb about a male found at the waterway somewhere near the Children’s museum. Then the body at the muddy river which was missing for 8 months, and now the body on Earth Day. Are you working to get more info?????? Is anyone? Do you have research partners—maybe the Crawlspace guys?

  14. wow. so i too have been investigating this and we should chat. I have been focused specifically upon the long wharf deaths as I myself found one body there back when I worked for BHC and then had a super hair raising experience with what I think was a serial killer on long wharf one night while I was investigating the body I found and reported.

    • what does BHC stand for? Do tell us more details about your hair-raising situation. This is for real and public safety is at risk. Was the body a young male without obvious signs of trauma? Did you find the body in the warm weather? Do you know the identity of the victim and the circumstances of his missing— does it fit these patterns?

  15. Hello,

    I know you are primarily focused on cases in the Boston area, but figured you might be interested in a very similar one from New Jersey.
    Matthew Genovese, 24, went missing 1/23/2016, after leaving a Hoboken bar blocks from the Hudson river. Being familiar with these cases, the first thing I thought when I heard this report was, “Watch them find him in the river.” Sure enough, even it was midnight during blizzard conditions (for which he was under-dressed), he apparently walked in the opposite direction of home and was found on 1/26 in the Hudson.

    More info: http://www.hudsonreporter.com/view/full_story/27066237/article-Into-the-blizzard–then-gone-Questions-linger-after-24-year-old-found-dead-in-Hudson-River-

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s